Moving to a new city sounds exciting. Many people picture bigger homes, more room, or an easier way of life. But a new survey found that the reality is sometimes very different. They asked more than 3,000 people who moved to a new state during the past five years. It looked at which cities gave newcomers the biggest surprise when it came to housing.

Four New York Cities Made the List

Four cities in New York were among those that surprised new residents the most. They were Buffalo, Rochester, New York City, and Yonkers.

New York City Brings the Biggest Shock

New York City ranked highest among the four New York cities. Many people said they were surprised by how small homes and apartments are. Storage space is limited and parking is hard to find.

Older Homes Surprise Many Movers

People who moved to Buffalo and Rochester said they liked the lower home prices but they were surprised by how old the homes are. They also found that winter weather, heating costs, and home repairs is a bigger challenge than they expected.

Yonkers Offers a Mix of City and Suburbs

Many people move to Yonkers because it is close to New York City. But some said they were surprised by the older buildings, limited parking, and how much neighborhoods can change from one area to another.

98.1 The Hawk logo
Get our free mobile app

Many People Still Miss Their Old Home

The survey found that over 60% of people who moved have, at least once, thought the homes where they used to live were better. So before you move, it helps to learn not just about home prices, but what everyday life is really like in a new place. See the entire list here.

Where People Are Moving To In New York In 2026

Where New Yorkers Are Moving To The Most

This list is based off  U-Haul 2025 Midyear Migration Trends

More From 98.1 The Hawk