Binghamton, This Is Not Who We Want To Be

I have stared at this story for hours, days, and still cannot fully wrap my head around it.

A 45-year-old Binghamton man, Peter Bennedum, is dead after police say he was brutally assaulted by a group of juveniles near Carroll and Henry Streets, allegedly as part of a horrifying social media trend where unhoused people are beaten, and the attacks are shared online for attention. Peter spent days in critical condition before dying from his injuries. Now, five children, including a 13-year-old, are facing murder charges.

Read that again.

A man is dead.

Children are accused of killing him.

And every single part of that sentence feels impossible to process.

A Human Being Lost His Life

Peter Bennedum was unhoused at the time of the assault, but let’s stop right there for a second because sometimes society gets dangerously numb when people are described that way.

He was still a human being.

Someone knew him. Someone loved him. Someone is now in the midst of the unimaginable reality of never seeing him again.

No matter what road brought Peter to that moment in life, he did not deserve to be beaten, and certainly so badly that he died.

What happened to this man was cruel, violent, and completely reprehensible.

And I don’t care how young someone is, there has to be accountability when another human being loses their life this way.

Five Young Lives Are Now Changed Forever

This story is heartbreaking from every angle because now five young people also face futures forever marked by violence, courtrooms, detention facilities, and headlines that will follow them for the rest of their lives.

That should shake every single one of us.

It’s deeply unsettling to think about what has to happen in a child’s life, heart, mind, environment, or sense of humanity for this level of violence to even feel possible.

Kids are not born full of this kind of rage.

So where are they learning it?

What are they seeing?

What are they carrying around inside themselves?

And who failed them long before police lights and murder charges entered the picture?

None of those questions excuse what allegedly happened. Not even close.

But if we refuse to ask them, we are missing part of the tragedy.

Binghamton Is Carrying A Heavy Weight

Binghamton has been through a lot lately.

You can feel it in conversations at the grocery store, in comment sections, in the way people talk about safety, addiction, mental health, poverty, violence, and hopelessness.

Stories like this land hard because they force us to look at things we’d rather believe could never happen here.

But they are happening here.

A man is dead.

A family is grieving.

Five young lives are shattered.

And there is nothing good, victorious, funny, or tough about any part of this story.

Just pain.

Get our free mobile app

We Cannot Become Numb To This

If there is one thing I hope for Binghamton, it’s that we never become so used to stories like this that they stop hurting.

Because the moment we stop feeling heartbreak over something like this is the moment we lose something important about ourselves, too.

This city still has good people. Compassionate people. People who care deeply about their neighbors and about the direction this community is headed.

We need more of that.

More humanity.

More intervention before violence.

More people paying attention to struggling kids before they become headlines.

More care for people society too often overlooks.

Because this entire story feels like a devastating collision of brokenness from every direction.

And today, Binghamton feels heavy.