If you live in New York State, you already know that pizza is part of our everyday lives. But a new study shows it is also more expensive here in the Empire State then in many other places.

Where New York Ranks

Two New York locations made the list of the most expensive places to buy pizza. Brookhaven ranked fifth, with an average price of $21.59 for a regular cheese pizza. New York City came in seventh, with an average price of $20.68. That means New York is near the top when it comes to pizza prices across the country.

What You’re Paying Per Slice

When you break it down, the cost adds up fast. In New York City, the average slice costs about $2.59, while Brookhaven is even higher at around $2.70 per slice. Compared to other cities, that’s a big difference.

98.1 The Hawk logo
Get our free mobile app

Why Prices May Be Higher

There are a couple of reasons for this. Higher rent, labor costs, and demand all are a part in pushing prices up across New York State. And because pizza is so popular here, people are willing to pay for it.

Some Cities Pay Less

In other parts of the country, pizza is much more affordable. Some cities average closer to $12 or $13 for a full pie, which is far less than what many New Yorkers are paying.

What This Means for You

If you’re grabbing a slice in New York, you might be paying more than most Americans. But for many people, it’s still worth it. After all, New York pizza has a reputation for a reason.

Six Places in the Southern Tier That Make Unique Pizza

Interesting in trying a pizza that packs a flavor punch that you're not used to? These are six places in the Southern Tier where you can try a unique flavored pizza!

Gallery Credit: Traci Taylor

LOOK: Top pizza chains in the US

To help you find your next slice, Stacker examined PMQ Pizza Magazine's 2025 Pizza Power report to round up the 30 biggest pizza chains in the country based on annual sales in 2023. Some are classic fast-food franchises, customizable and deliverable to our doorsteps in less than 60 minutes; others are brick-and-mortar family joints.

Gallery Credit: Stacker

More From 98.1 The Hawk