What New Yorkers Are Serving For The Fourth Of July This Year

We need to talk about your cooler.

With July 4th coming up, this is not just any summer cookout season. This year, America turns 250 years old, and whether you're watching fireworks reflect off Seneca Lake, grilling in your backyard in Syracuse, spreading out a blanket on the shores of Lake George, or staking out your favorite spot at Highland Park with a lawn chair and a cooler, you're going to want your food spread to be worthy of the occasion. A 250th birthday calls for more than a sad paper plate of potato salad.

And as it turns out, the rest of the country is already ahead of you on that.

Your Potato Salad Is Not Going to Make It

A new survey just dropped the picnic food power rankings, and some of the results are going to sting a little. The foods Americans are moving away from this summer include Spam, cocktail sausages, corned beef, sliced white bread, cheap potato chips, cheddar cheese slices, mayonnaise, and yes, potato salad.

Look, nobody is here to attack your grandmother's recipe. I LOVE a good potato salad, and yours has probably shown up at every family Fourth of July since roughly 1987, earning its place in the rotation. But the survey has spoken, and apparently, the crowd is ready to try something new.

So What Is Everyone Eating Now?

Here is where it gets interesting. The foods exploding in popularity this summer read less like a backyard cookout list and more like a menu from that wine bar on the corner that you keep meaning to try. We're talking olives, flatbreads, breadsticks, hummus, chorizo, salami, prosciutto, focaccia, Spanish tortilla, and halloumi, a Mediterranean cheese you can actually throw directly on the grill.

Read that list again. Grillable cheese. That's a thing now, and apparently everyone is doing it.

New York Was Already On This

Here's the thing: New Yorkers shouldn't be too surprised by any of this. Walk through any farmers' market from the North Fork to the Catskills, and you'll find exactly these kinds of spreads already laid out on folding tables. The corner deli in your neighborhood has probably had good olives and imported meats behind the glass for years. New York has always had access to this stuff. The rest of the country is just now catching up.

So if you've been quietly assembling a charcuterie situation for your Fourth of July gathering while everyone else argued about who was bringing the pasta salad, congratulations. You were ahead of the curve.

Building the Perfect 250th Birthday Spread

If you're pulling together a picnic or backyard situation for the big day, here's the move. Grab a solid flatbread or some focaccia from your local bakery. Pick up a handful of olives from the deli counter. Throw some halloumi on the grill next to your hot dogs and watch people completely lose their minds over it. Add some salami and prosciutto, a little hummus on the side, and you have something that feels both effortless and like you actually tried.

America is turning 250. The least we can do is bring decent snacks.

Get our free mobile app

The Spam Is Not Invited

To be fair to the classics, there is something genuinely nostalgic about a lot of the foods on the declining list. Cocktail sausages on a toothpick, a stack of cheddar slices, and a big bowl of potato salad covered in plastic wrap. These are the flavors of every Fourth of July most of us grew up with, and there's real comfort in that.

But nostalgia and dinner are two different things. This summer, especially this summer, with the whole country gathered together to celebrate something big, maybe it's worth trying something new alongside the old favorites. Keep the traditions that matter. Update the ones that don't.

Just maybe leave the Spam at home this time.