True Crime Podcast Craze: Take a Dive into New York’s Favorites!

Hey there, podcast people of the Empire State! Have you found yourself sucked into the world of true crime podcasts? From unsolved mysteries to spine-chilling tales, it seems like true crime shows have been taking over our earbuds all across the country.

So what do New Yorkers think when it comes to these podcasts?  Let's take a closer look at the most popular true crime podcasts in the state, and how often New York becomes the backdrop of these chilling stories.

New Yorkers' Top Picks

When it comes to the gritty world of crime, it turns out that "Rotten Mango" is a huge hit in the Empire State. This podcast presents lesser-known, international true crime stories, giving us a different perspective that keeps us on the edge of our seats.

Maybe it's the endless hustle and bustle of city life that is woven into the state's history – whatever it is, "Rotten Mango" has landed a place in the hearts of true crime fans here in New York.

Get our free mobile app

Another favorite is "My Favorite Murder." It's a blend of true crime storytelling and comedy, Karen and Georgia have been keeping listeners hooked for years and New York is showing them some love.

New York as the Crime Scene

How often is New York featured as the backdrop for true crime tales? From gritty downtown crime sagas to eerie upstate mysteries, New York has been the setting for 5.6% of the episodes in the true crime podcast universe.

Who can forget the infamous Son of Sam case or the Long Island Serial Killer? These are just some of the dark tales that have come from the streets and neighborhoods of New York.

Whether you're a fan of "Rotten Mango" or find you love the storytelling of "My Favorite Murder," there's no denying that New York has its pulse on the true crime podcast craze.