New York Killer’s Conviction Tossed in Etan Patz Case Bombshell

On a spring morning in 1979, 6-year-old Etan Patz left his family’s apartment in the SoHo neighborhood of Lower Manhattan. It was the first time his mom let him walk to the school bus stop alone which was only a block and a half away. She walked him downstairs, watched him head off, and never saw him again.

Etan’s disappearance shook New York, and the country, to its core. His face became one of the first to appear on milk cartons, and his case helped launch a national movement to protect missing children.

The Case That Changed Everything

Etan wasn’t just a little boy from New York who vanished without a trace, his case changed the way America handles missing children. After his disappearance, new laws were passed, national hotlines were created, and police agencies started working together in ways they hadn’t before. In 1983, President Ronald Reagan declared May 25, Etan’s disappearance date, as National Missing Children’s Day.

Decades of Searching, and a Break in the Case

Etan’s parents, Julie and Stan Patz, never moved from their apartment. They even kept the same phone number, just in case their son ever tried to reach them. But years went by with no answers. In 2001, a civil court officially declared Etan dead.

The case was reopened in 2010 by the Manhattan District Attorney’s office. Two years later, the FBI searched a basement near the Patz home, hoping to find evidence. They came up empty. But that same year, police got a tip about a man named Pedro Hernandez who had allegedly told people years earlier that he’d killed a child in New York.

A Confession With a Lot of Questions

Hernandez had been a teenager working in a convenience store in Etan’s neighborhood back in 1979. When police questioned him in 2012, he confessed. He told them he lured Etan into the basement with the promise of a soda, strangled him, and left his body in a box with the trash.

READ MORE: Upstate New York AMBER Alert Ends in Heartbreak

But there were problems. Hernandez wasn’t read his Miranda rights until seven hours into questioning. And his defense attorneys argued that his confession wasn’t reliable. They said Hernandez had serious mental health issues and a very low IQ. His own daughter testified that he saw visions of angels and demons and once tried to water a dead tree branch, thinking it would grow.

Two Trials, One Controversial Verdict

Hernandez’s first trial in 2015 ended in a hung jury when one juror held out, and no verdict was reached. A second trial began in 2016 and lasted months. In February 2017, a jury found him guilty of second-degree murder and first-degree kidnapping. He was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.

Still, not everyone was convinced they had the right man. The defense pointed to another suspect, a convicted child molester, who had made strange, possibly incriminating statements over the years. But he was never charged.

Now, the Conviction Has Been Thrown Out

On July 21, 2025, nearly 46 years after Etan vanished, a federal appeals court threw out Hernandez’s conviction. Why? Because of the judge’s response to a key question from jurors during deliberations. They asked if they had to disregard Hernandez’s videotaped confessions if they believed his original, unrecorded confession wasn’t valid. The judge said no. But the appeals court says that was the wrong answer, the jury should have been told they could disregard all the confessions.

The court called the judge’s instructions “clearly wrong” and “manifestly prejudicial.” Now, unless the state holds a new trial soon, Hernandez could be released.

No Easy Answers, Even After All This Time

The Manhattan District Attorney’s office, which prosecuted the case, says it’s reviewing the court’s decision. Etan’s parents haven’t commented publicly, but their decades of advocacy helped create a national system for how America now responds when a child goes missing.

Etan’s Legacy Lives On

Even without a final answer in court, Etan Patz left behind a powerful legacy. His disappearance changed how parents watch over their children, how law enforcement handles missing child cases, and how the country responds when a child vanishes.

Get our free mobile app

Every year on May 25, people across the country honor National Missing Children’s Day and remember the little New York boy whose face on a milk carton sparked a nationwide movement.