Can the Amish Be Arrested? What New York State Law Actually Says

During a recent stay at my sister’s house, I spent a few days watching her next-door neighbors, a lovely Amish family, go about their daily routine. It got me thinking about how their traditional world intersects with ours.

If you drive through rural stretches of New York State, from the Mohawk Valley down to Chautauqua County, you are bound to share the roads with horse-drawn buggies. The Amish community’s distinct lifestyle and rejection of modern technology often lead neighbors to wonder: Are they exempt from modern laws, and can an Amish person actually be arrested?

The short answer is yes, absolutely. But the way the law plays out in the real world has a few fascinating twists that most New Yorkers don't know.

1. Zero Sovereignty: The Law Applies Equally

There is an ongoing rumor that the Amish operate under a form of sovereign immunity. This is completely false.

The Amish are private citizens subject to the exact same local, state, and federal laws as every other resident of New York. If a crime is committed, local sheriff's deputies, New York State Police, or federal agents have full authority to investigate and make an arrest.

The Reality Check: While the Amish church handles internal moral infractions through a strict process called Meidung (shunning), this has zero standing in a New York criminal court. Internal community rules never replace state law.

2. Buggies and the New York Traffic Loophole

The most frequent interaction between the Amish community and New York law enforcement happens on public roads, and it brings up some unique legal questions.

• The DWI Catch: Can you get a classic DWI while driving a horse and buggy? Technically, New York State’s drunk driving laws strictly specify motor vehicles. However, if someone operates a buggy while heavily intoxicated, law enforcement will absolutely arrest them under charges like Reckless Endangerment or Disorderly Conduct.
• The Orange Triangle Debate: New York State Vehicle and Traffic Law requires "slow-moving vehicles" to display a reflective amber triangle. While some highly conservative sects historically resisted this as a reliance on worldly technology, New York courts have consistently ruled that public safety outweighs religious objection.

3. Real-World Arrests and Cooperation

When serious crimes occur within the community, New York law enforcement steps in immediately. Amish individuals have been arrested, booked into county jails, and sentenced to state prison for everything from financial fraud to serious domestic abuse cases in rural counties.

Another thing is that the Amish community actively cooperates with outside law enforcement during crises. For instance, when two young Amish girls were kidnapped from a St. Lawrence County farm stand, Amish elders worked directly alongside the FBI and State Police to help track down and convict the perpetrators.

Get our free mobile app

The Ultimate Takeaway

The Amish choose to live separate from modern society, but they do not live separate from the law. When it comes to public welfare, the New York State Penal Law makes no distinctions based on religious tradition.