Dan Shafer and Sundance Head battled it out on The Voice Monday evening (Oct. 10) with a sultry cover of Bad Company's "Feel Like Makin' Love." The two singers showcased their soulful voices throughout the delivery of the song, making for a very difficult decision for Blake Shelton.

As it turns out, coaches Adam Levine, Miley Cyrus and Alicia Keys were into the performance, and their enthusiasm certainly rolled off on Shelton.

"I was in my element," Cyrus said of rocking out during the song, as Shelton quipped that he can now envision what a concert or house party with Cyrus feels like.

Keys praised Sundance, saying he is his "own beautiful beam. It's not easy to control the voice the way you control it while being so free and wild."

Levine added that he wished the performance wasn't over. "I just love what took place on that stage. I wish you guys could play it again it was so much fun," he said.

After praising both of his teammates, Shelton had to narrow it down to one contestant, ultimately choosing Sundance Head, because as the country star explains:

"Sundance, even as he's standing there right now he's like a statue. It's like, are you alive? Are you breathing? That's the thing about Sundance, it's like, what's going to happen? Then all of a sudden that voice comes out of there and it literally blows the brains out of my head, into the toilet, and the toilet flushes itself."

Every Blake Shelton Single Ranked in Order